SPHERICAL NEAR FIELD RADOME TEST FACILITY FOR NOSE-MOUNTED RADOMES OF AIRCRAFT
**** Hidden Message ***** SPHERICAL NEAR FIELD RADOME TEST FACILITY FOR NOSE-MOUNTED<BR>RADOMES OF COMMERCIAL TRAFFIC AIRCRAFT<BR>Marcel Boumans marcelb@orbitfr.de<BR>Ulrike Wagner ulrikew@orbitfr.de<BR>ORBIT/FR-Europe GmbH<BR>Johann-Sebastian-Bach-Str. 11, 85591 Vaterstetten, Germany<BR>ABSTRACT<BR>Typically radome tests are performed on outdoor far field<BR>ranges or compact ranges. ORBIT/FR has designed, build<BR>and qualified a unique spherical near-field radome test<BR>facility for the nose-mounted radomes of commercial<BR>traffic aircraft for the so-called “after repair” tests<BR>according to the international standard RTCA/DO-213, as<BR>well as the aircraft manufacturers Component<BR>Maintenance Manuals. The facility is extremely compact<BR>(chamber size 5.7 m x 5.2 m x 3.2 + 0.7 m, L x W x H),<BR>can handle radomes as small as used on the Canadair and<BR>as large as used on the Airbus-380 and can be installed<BR>directly in the repair workshop for such radomes.<BR>The tests performed are transmission efficiency and side<BR>lobe level increase. The system is completely automated,<BR>so that a workshop technician can operate the facility.<BR>Utmost attention has been paid to operational aspects and<BR>both operator and equipment safety.<BR>After the measurements are done, a test report is fully<BR>automatically generated according to RTCA requirements<BR>and classifications. The facility is equipped to test all<BR>standard Airbus, Boeing, Canadair and Dash nose<BR>radomes.<BR>Keywords: Radome Measurements, Transmission<BR>Efficiency, Sidelobe Increase, Spherical Near Field<BR>1. Introduction<BR>RTCA Inc. is a not-for-profit corporation formed to<BR>advance the art and science of aviation and aviation<BR>electronic systems for the benefit of the public. The<BR>organization functions as a Federal Advisory Committee<BR>and develops consensus based recommendations on<BR>contemporary aviation issues.<BR>The RTCA/DO-213 standard is defined in the documents<BR>“Minimum Operational Performance Standards for Nose-<BR>Mounted Radomes” dated Jan 14, 1993, with “Change<BR>No. 1 to RTCA/DO-213 Minimum Operational<BR>Performance Standards for Nose-Mounted Radomes”,<BR>dated Jun 23, 1995.<BR>The presented test facility allows RF testing compliant to<BR>the RTCA/DO-213 standard, in particular for<BR>Transmission Efficiency and Side Lobe Level Increase<BR>(the so-called “after repair” test requirements). Software<BR>modifications to also include Incident Reflection, Beam<BR>Deflection and Beam Width are under development. This<BR>facility is not intended for any of the environmental tests<BR>also defined in document RTCA/DO-213.<BR>In addition the aircraft manufacturers requirements,<BR>which sometimes define deviations from the standard<BR>RTCA/DO-213, are taken into account. In particular the<BR>Airbus Component Maintenance Manual (CMM) requires<BR>sidelobe measurements throughout the entire predictive<BR>windshear (PWS) electromagnetic window, where<BR>RTCA/DO-213 requires this only in the forward<BR>direction.<BR>The facility design is unique in that it is based on antenna<BR>near field technology. This allows to reduce the size of<BR>the facility significantly, so that it can be build indoor,<BR>and can be environmentally controlled. This reduces<BR>infrastructure cost and increases availability and<BR>accuracy. The acquired data is transformed to the far<BR>field, so that the data analysis is based on highly accurate<BR>far-field data.<BR>It can be used for Qualification/Preproduction Testing,<BR>Quality Assurance/Production Testing and so called After<BR>Repair Testing. The facility is designed for use with a<BR>multitude of radomes, for easy and safe handling of these<BR>radomes, and for fast and efficient testing. In particular<BR>for production and after repair testing, the facility is<BR>highly automated, so that workshop personnel not<BR>familiar with RF testing can easily do RTCA/DO-213<BR>compliant testing. Test reports are generated fully<BR>automatic.<BR>Since the design is based on standard antenna / radome<BR>test technologies, the advanced user can perform a<BR>multitude of tests beyond what is defined in the<BR>RTCA/DO-213. Thus this facility also presents a sound<BR>investment for future standards and applications.<BR>2. Facility Overview<BR>Figure 1. shows the ORBIT/FR near field radome test<BR>facility for nose-mounted radomes. The near field probing<BR>surface is spherical. The positioning is realized with a fast<BR>rotating azimuth positioner (30 rpm), which carries the<BR>Device Under Test (radome, radar antenna on gimbal<BR>positioner, aircraft bulkhead, where applicable), and an<BR>elevation arm. Note that the orientation of the facility is<BR>such that the aircraft “flies” to the zenith of the facility.<BR>Figure 1. General overview of test facility<BR>The test facility chamber outside dimensions are approx.<BR>5.7 m x 5.2 m x 3.9 m (W x L x H), with a pit for the<BR>azimuth positioner of 0.7 m deep. Thus it can be easily<BR>installed right in the radome workshop. Access inside the<BR>facility is through a large double leaved door of 4.0 m x<BR>3.3 m (W x H). Typically the chamber is build as a<BR>shielded, self supporting structure, so that there is no<BR>interaction / disturbance from the radar signals inside the<BR>facility with the outside world and vice versa. The inside<BR>of the chamber is installed with 200 mm pyramidal<BR>absorbers everywhere. In those areas of the floor where<BR>people have to be for installation purposes, so-called<BR>walk-on absorbers are installed.<BR>Figure 2. The facility “as built”<BR>All the instrumentation is mounted in a rack inside the<BR>test chamber, right next to the elevation positioner. The<BR>system is controlled through Fiber Optic LAN by either a<BR>computer directly next to the facility, or optionally any<BR>other computer connected to the same network.<BR>The RF system is based on a network analyzer. For<BR>Production testing and After Repair Testing, typically a<BR>single frequency is used (e.g. 9.35 GHz), for<BR>Qualification Testing multiple frequencies between 9.3<BR>and 9.5 GHz are used. The RF probe on the elevation arm<BR>is a dual linear polarized single choke circular probe.<BR>Figure 3. Radar antenna under the radome<BR>Facility temperature control is through one inlet into and<BR>one outlet out of the test chamber, and can either be<BR>connected to the building air conditioning supply or a<BR>separate unit just for this facility. Note that the absolute<BR>temperature does not need to be as strictly controlled as<BR>the temperature variation during one measurement (+17<BR>to +28 deg C versus ± 2 deg).<BR>The radar antenna is mounted on the gimbal positioner,<BR>which has a travel of ± 88 deg in azimuth and ± 33 deg in<BR>elevation (relative to the aircraft). An automated linear<BR>translation of approx. 8 mm (representing ¼ λ in X-band)<BR>is installed between the radar antenna and the gimbal.<BR>Note that RTCA/DO-213 requires the transmission<BR>measurements to be done in two antenna positions<BR>separated by ¼ λ in the boresight direction.<BR>The entire gimbal unit is installed on a vertical slide<BR>which allows to position the unit at the correct position<BR>inside the radome. In addition this allows to lower the<BR>radar antenna below the radome mounting surface, so that<BR>it is protected while a new radome is being installed.<BR>Figure 4. Radar antenna in low position for easy radome<BR>mounting<BR>The facility is designed to be able to handle a multitude of<BR>different radomes with a minimum of operator<BR>adjustments. For this purpose, each different size of<BR>radome is mounted on its own support plate, made out of<BR>a light weight fibre reinforced plastic honeycomb<BR>sandwich structure. Thus it can easily be adapted to<BR>include the aircraft bulkhead or to include the real<BR>aircrafts interface (hinges, latches, screws), or any other<BR>means to position and hold the radome. Since the<BR>radomes are supported by these plates and point upright,<BR>the loads on the interfaces are relatively small.<BR>The plates are coded such that it is not possible to move<BR>the antenna inside the radome to a position which would<BR>allow the antenna to hit the radome. Also the interface<BR>between the support plate and the azimuth positioner is<BR>designed such that the radome is automatically mounted<BR>correctly in radial and axial directions.<BR>In this way most radomes can be mounted and<BR>dismounted by just two or three people who carry the<BR>support plate with radome into and out of the facility.<BR>This action only takes a few minutes.<BR>3. Facility Control<BR>The operation of the facility is highly automated for the<BR>measurement types described in the RTCA/DO-213, and<BR>minimum antenna and RF knowledge is necessary to<BR>perform these tests according to the RTCA/DO-213<BR>requirements. The measurements can typically be<BR>executed from fully automated batches, provided by<BR>ORBIT/FR.<BR>On the other hand, there is still a lot of flexibility in<BR>regard to variation from the pre-defined measurements.<BR>Such variation can consist of selecting a sub-set of the<BR>gimbal angles (e.g. to concentrate on an area of the<BR>radome where improvement or repair is necessary) and of<BR>selecting reduced RF sampling ranges (e.g. to speed up<BR>measurement time for indicative measurements).<BR>3.1 Test facility and test preparation<BR>Presuming the facility is powered off, first the test facility<BR>needs to be powered on, temperature stabilize and the<BR>applicable radar antenna needs to be mounted (if there is<BR>a large variation in the sizes of the radomes to be tested,<BR>also the radar antennas need to be available in different<BR>diameters). Then data is entered in regard to the test<BR>radome (e.g. Type and Serial Number).<BR>Detailed instructions for the operator appear on the<BR>computer monitor.<BR>3.2 Measurement selection and execution<BR>First the test standard is selected (RTCA/DO-213 resp.<BR>CMM or customer defined “Fast Check”), the<BR>measurement types are selected (Transmission Efficiency,<BR>Side Lobe Levels and Beamwidth, Incident Reflection<BR>and / or Beam Deflection). Note that for “After Repair<BR>Testing” only Transmission Efficiency and, in some<BR>cases, Side Lobe Level Increase are required.<BR>Then the gimbal angles are selected (full set, as defined in<BR>RTCA/DO-213 resp. CMM, or partial set).<BR>Before measurements can be started, the temperature of<BR>the facility needs to be stabilized to within ± 2 deg of the<BR>reference temperature (see also Chapter 2), each time the<BR>large doors have been opened. Note that if the reference<BR>temperature is close to the temperature outside of the test<BR>chamber, no waiting times would be required.<BR>Now a calibration (reference) measurement is made of the<BR>radar antenna without the radome. Then the radome is<BR>mounted and, after the temperature is stabilized again, the<BR>measurements can be performed fully automated. At the<BR>end of all measurements the radome is removed again,<BR>and a second reference of the radar antenna without<BR>radome is performed to verify that the facility was stable<BR>during the measurements.<BR>3.3 Data Analysis and Reporting<BR>After the measurements are finished, test reports are<BR>generated automatically. For “Fast Check” or “Partial<BR>Check” the statement at the lower end of the report will<BR>then state that these measurements were NOT executed in<BR>accordance to RTCA/DO-213 and / or CMM.<BR>4. Safety<BR>Many safety aspects have been included in the design and<BR>implementation of the Radome Test Facility. These<BR>aspects relate to both equipment safety (test facility<BR>including radar antenna and radomes) as well as<BR>personnel safety.<BR>4.1 Equipment Safety<BR>The equipment safety relates to the risk that any<BR>component of the test facility, or the radome under test,<BR>can get damaged in operation. In particular, if many<BR>different sizes of radomes are to be tested, then such a<BR>risk is real: if a large radome was measured, and after that<BR>a much smaller radome is to be measured, then the radar<BR>antenna could hit the radome wall if the facility would not<BR>correctly be set up to handle the much smaller radome.<BR>If the system is only used for regular weather radar tests,<BR>then it is only operated at frequencies from 9.3 to 9.5<BR>GHz. Thus nothing needs to be changed to the RF<BR>instrumentation, including the RF probe, at any time. The<BR>RF probe on the elevation arm is normally parked at the<BR>ceiling of the facility near the “zenith” position when any<BR>person has to work inside the facility. This reduces the<BR>risk that the arm and the RF probe are damaged during<BR>installation work.<BR>Before the radomes are installed in the facility, they are<BR>fitted to support plates unique to the radomes, with<BR>handles or other devices to carry the plate / radome<BR>assembly. The radomes are mounted upright on the<BR>azimuth positioner (the aircraft is “flying” to the zenith of<BR>the facility). This makes the assemblies easy to carry and<BR>install. It will be difficult to install a radome on the wrong<BR>support plate by virtue of clear indications and<BR>instructions on the plates, the size of the plates relative to<BR>the radomes, or the interfaces between the plates and the<BR>radomes. The support plates are fitted with hardware<BR>coding which allows to install the plate to the azimuth<BR>positioner in only the correct way, and which give<BR>information to the test facility about the position of the<BR>radar antenna inside the radome.<BR>The installation platform is 0.8 m above the chamber<BR>inside floor level, so that installation personnel has best<BR>handling control of both the size and the weight of the<BR>radomes. The radar antenna is lowered below the support<BR>plate interface frame before a new radome is installed.<BR>Thus it is virtually impossible to damage the radar<BR>antenna with the radome during installation.<BR>Lifting and lowering of the gimbal positioner is done<BR>automatically by the software. The radar antenna can only<BR>be lowered below the interface frame when the gimbal is<BR>set close to zero azimuth and zero elevation because of a<BR>limit switch interlock mechanism included in the gimbal<BR>positioner / vertical lift, thus preventing that the radar<BR>antenna hits the interface frame. The radar antenna cannot<BR>be lifted to a height which would allow the antenna to hit<BR>the radome wall, because the support plate includes limit<BR>switch information for the vertical lift.<BR>4.2 Personnel Safety<BR>Personnel safety relates to the risk that an operator of the<BR>facility, or any other person, gets hurt by this facility.<BR>This relates to mechanical, electrical and RF aspects.<BR>In a machine with moving parts, there is always the risk<BR>that somebody gets hit or squeezed by any of these parts.<BR>In this facility, with the 30 rpm azimuth positioner which<BR>can carry very large radomes, the gimbal positioner on<BR>which radar antennas need to be mounted, etc., such risks<BR>need to be carefully considered. Through design,<BR>instructions and training this risk needs to be minimized.<BR>Several hardware measures have been included in this<BR>facility to increase the personnel safety.<BR>Emergency stop buttons are included in three locations:<BR>one near the elevation positioner, one near the door and<BR>one outside the chamber, typically near the control<BR>computer.<BR>Also a switch is connected to the door, which disables<BR>any positioner movement as soon as the door is opened.<BR>This will prevent that anybody not familiar with the<BR>facility, who could enter the facility unintended, cannot<BR>get hurt by any moving parts.<BR>Further a shielded window is installed in one of the<BR>facility walls, as well as a video network camera inside<BR>the facility. Thus the operator can easily make a final<BR>check before starting the measurement. The camera can<BR>be accessed through any computer on the network, so that<BR>one can also have a regular look inside the facility for<BR>long unattended measurements.<BR>From the operational and health point of view carrying<BR>and handling heavy and large objects, the facility is<BR>optimized by having a very large door of 4 m wide, a<BR>single step of only 5 cm from the outside to the inside of<BR>the facility (walk-on absorbers) and by having the<BR>installation platform at 80 cm height.<BR>In regard to the electrical safety, the standard national and<BR>international electrical wiring and installation standards<BR>are followed.<BR>In regard to RF safety, the transmitted power is very low<BR>(less than 50 mW). In addition, the facility is typically<BR>build inside a shielded chamber. This is primarily to<BR>prevent interference from weather radar signals from real<BR>aircraft in the vicinity of the facility, or to prevent the<BR>signals from the facility to interfere with weather radar<BR>signals from real aircraft, but also lowers the radiation<BR>outside the facility to undetectable levels.<BR>5. Test Results<BR>First the facility has been tested on stability and<BR>reproducibility. This means that all 45 antenna / gimbal<BR>combinations have been measured repeatedly, and<BR>variation in the angles of the beam peak as well as in the<BR>maximum power level have been compared.<BR>Repeatability in beam peak angle has been shown to be<BR>better than ± 0.1 deg. Note that the power variation of the<BR>beam peak within this angular range is only ± 0.02 dB, or<BR>less than ± 0.5 %.<BR>Repeatability in power level at the beam peak has been<BR>shown to be better than ± 0.05 dB, or ± 1 % between the<BR>reference measurements with which a radome test is<BR>started and the final reference measurement after all<BR>radome measurements are finished. Note that up to 14<BR>hours can be between these two measurements for a large<BR>radome.<BR>These stability and repeatability results are well within<BR>the requirements stated in RTCA/DO-213.<BR>The following tables and plots show some typical test<BR>results for both a typical Kevlar (Class C) and a high<BR>quality quartz glass (Class A) radome. Note that the<BR>shown tables and graphs are generated fully automated.<BR>Customer specific logos, test object information and<BR>signature fields can be added according to the customer<BR>requirements.<BR>Figure 5. Transmission Loss of typical Kevlar radome<BR>Figure 6. Sidelobe Increase of typical Kevlar radome<BR>Figure 7. Transmission Loss of high quality quartz glass<BR>radome<BR>Figure 8. Sidelobe Increase of high quality quartz glass<BR>radome<BR>6. Measurement times<BR>In the spherical NF measurement system, the phi-axis<BR>rotates at 30 rpm, thus makes one revolution in 2 seconds.<BR>The theta axis, which is the step axis, needs approx. 2<BR>seconds to move to the next theta position.<BR>A large radome, like on a Boeing 747, requires an<BR>acquisition step angle of 0.72 deg. This presumes that any<BR>part of the radome can reflect some radiation (eg.<BR>reflection lobes), which is the worst case assumption.<BR>For a full characterisation of the radome / antenna system<BR>the theta axis needs to be scanned from 0 (zenith) to<BR>slightly beyond 90 degrees (horizon), resulting in approx.<BR>9 minutes for a single measurement. A fully compliant<BR>RTCA “after repair” test requires 45 gimbal positions at 2<BR>“quarter wavelength” positions of the antenna, plus two<BR>reference measurements, or a total of 92 measurements.<BR>Thus the total measurement time for a B-747 radome is in<BR>the order of 14 hours.<BR>A smaller radome, like used on a DASH, requires 1.44<BR>deg increments, and results in total measurements times<BR>in the order of 8 hours.<BR>These test times have been confirmed in practice.<BR>Although the test times for the largest types of radomes<BR>are quite long, it must be realized that the facility operates<BR>fully automated, and no operator actions are required<BR>from after the radome is mounted until all 2 x 45 gimbal<BR>angles are measured and the radome can be removed<BR>again. Thus, in practice, one to two radomes can be<BR>measured per day, which is typically more than sufficient<BR>for a radome repair workshop.<BR>If higher measurement speeds are required, then more<BR>probes can be mounted on the elevation arm.<BR>7. Conclusions<BR>A very compact RTCA/DO-213 compliant “after repair”<BR>RF test facility has been build and qualified, but also<BR>Qualification / Preproduction and Quality Assurance /<BR>Production Testing defined in RTCA/DO-213 can be<BR>tested with this facility.<BR>It can be installed in the repair workshop and can be<BR>operated by workshop personnel. Tests are made and<BR>evaluated fully automated.<BR>Since this avoids packing for and transportation to an<BR>external RF test facility, significantly reduced repair times<BR>can be realized.<BR>8. REFERENCES<BR> “Minimum Operational Performance Standards for<BR>Nose-Mounted Radomes” dated Jan 14, 1993, with<BR>“Change No. 1 to RTCA/DO-213 Minimum Operational<BR>Performance Standards for Nose-Mounted Radomes”,<BR>dated Jun 23, 1995,<BR> “CMM Component Maintenance Manual”, various<BR>Aircraft models, Airbus Industrie, 什么内容的呀 study hard回复 1# 航空 的帖子
南京航空航天大学民航学院,江苏南京210016)
页:
[1]