SINGLE EUROPEAN SKY Results from the transport research programme
**** Hidden Message ***** Results from<BR>the transport research programme<BR>SINGLE EUROPEAN SKY<BR>EUROPEAN<BR>COMMISSION<BR>Information on the wider transport activities of the European Union is also available<BR>on the Internet. It can be accessed through the Europa server<BR>(http://europa.eu.int/comm/dgs/energy_transport/index_en.html).<BR>Manuscript completed in July 2001.<BR>Luxembourg:Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, 2001<BR>ISBN 92-894-1550-9<BR>© European Communities, 2001<BR>Cover pictures: Eureka Slide.<BR>Photographs shown on page 7 have been provided by Eureka Slide (1, 2 ,4).<BR>Reproduction is authorised provided the source is acknowledged.<BR>Printed in Belgium.<BR>This brochure was produced by the EXTRA consortium for DG Energy and Transport and represents<BR>the consortium’s views on research relating to air transport.These views have not been adopted or<BR>in any way approved by the Commission and should not be relied upon as a statement of<BR>the Commission's or DG Energy and Transport's views.The European Commission does not guarantee<BR>the accuracy of the data included in this brochure, nor does it accept responsibility for any use<BR>made thereof.<BR>Frequently used acronyms<BR>A-SMGCS Advanced Surface Movement Guidance and Control System<BR>ATC Air Traffic Control<BR>ATM Air Traffic Management<BR>CNS Communication, Navigation and Surveillance<BR>Eurocontrol European Organisation for the Safety of Air Navigation<BR>JAA Joint Aviation Authorities<BR>Additional information on the transport research programme is available on the Internet.<BR>The programme’s Knowledge Centre (http://europa.eu.int/comm/transport/extra/home.html)<BR>provides:<BR>• structured guides to the results and projects for particular topics;<BR>• summaries and final reports of individual projects;<BR>• access to project web sites and other contact details.<BR>References to some projects are included in this brochure, to help the reader access<BR>further information quickly through the Knowledge Centre.<BR>2 3<BR>ir transport makes an increasingly<BR>vital contribution to the economy<BR>and society1, and is at the heart of<BR>globalisation. But traffic growth in the<BR>aviation sector is rapidly taking away the<BR>benefits, through impacts such as delays,<BR>noise and pollution. Innovative policies and<BR>technologies can reduce these impacts and<BR>promote a more sustainable outcome.<BR>Therefore, through its transport research<BR>programme2, the European Community has<BR>targeted a range of actions to help develop<BR>effective solutions.<BR>This brochure highlights research results<BR>that will help to establish a Single European<BR>Sky. Its purpose is to raise awareness of<BR>the information and decision support that<BR>is now available, and to encourage readers<BR>to obtain further details through<BR>a web-based Knowledge Centre<BR>(http://europa.eu.int/comm/transport/<BR>extra/home.html).<BR>THE NEED FOR RESEARCH<BR>In this brochure, discover how research<BR>can contribute to future policy for<BR>one harmonised airspace over Europe,<BR>and identify topics worth investigating<BR>further on the web.<BR>A<BR>SINGLE EUROPEAN SKY<BR>Coping with air traffic growth<BR>Air transport demand has been growing<BR>steadily at between 5 and 7 percent over<BR>recent years and this rate of growth is<BR>expected to continue for the foreseeable<BR>future, leading to at least a doubling in traffic<BR>every 12 years. For instance, in the year 2000,<BR>European air traffic grew by nearly 8%,<BR>compared to 6% globally.This is creating<BR>serious capacity problems for air traffic<BR>management and bottlenecks at airports.<BR>Whilst improvements have been made to<BR>the national air traffic management (ATM)<BR>systems that constitute the European system,<BR>these improvements have not kept pace<BR>with demand, with the result that delays<BR>remain at unacceptably high levels.The<BR>latest data for June 2001 show that 22%<BR>of all flights were delayed by more than<BR>15 minutes.<BR>The ongoing problem of delays led<BR>the European Council in 1999 to request a<BR>comprehensive reform of European air<BR>traffic management. As a result, by 2005 the<BR>EU should have in place the framework for<BR>a seamless ATM system.This will improve<BR>the safety of air transport through better<BR>co-ordination at Community level, while at<BR>the same time increasing capacity for traffic<BR>growth through more efficient use of<BR>airspace.<BR>Key areas of immediate action towards<BR>the goal of a Single European Sky are:<BR>• Safety – establishing a European<BR>Aviation Safety Agency and a safety action<BR>programme;<BR>• Airspace management – enabling a single<BR>European airspace through the integrated<BR>management of air traffic;<BR>• Integration of military needs – securing<BR>civil/military co-operation on airspace<BR>usage and management;<BR>• Systems and operations – introducing<BR>common technical solutions, regulations<BR>and standards;<BR>• Framework for providers of air traffic<BR>control – regulating and providing national<BR>services compliant with EC requirements;and<BR>• Social aspects – improving recruitment,<BR>training and operational procedures.<BR>The key policy issue lies in achieving<BR>improvements in three major categories:<BR>harmonising the safe and efficient<BR>management of airspace across Europe,<BR>tackling rapidly growing bottlenecks at<BR>airports, and adapting human operators<BR>and users to new technologies in<BR>the whole sector. Research has been<BR>focused accordingly.<BR>The latest data<BR>for June 2001 show<BR>that 22% of all flights<BR>were delayed by more<BR>than 15 minutes, with<BR>the average delay<BR>per delayed flight<BR>exceeding 22 minutes.<BR>© Eureka Slide, Houze<BR>KEY RESULTS<BR>Research projects have a major impact on policy<BR>towards a Single European Sky. Selected highlights are<BR>described in this Section.<BR>Shaping the future Air Traffic<BR>Management (ATM) architecture<BR>ir Traffic Management (ATM) capacity<BR>is a scarce resource that needs<BR>careful deployment.This requires<BR>the open exchange of data to ensure<BR>that decision making is located where it is<BR>most effective. New operational concepts<BR>and systems are required that permit<BR>aircraft to operate in all weather conditions<BR>and fly safely at reduced separation.<BR>Such systems should also support<BR>the efficient allocation of airspace, while<BR>limiting as far as possible the need for new<BR>airport infrastructure.<BR>Research has identified effective options<BR>for improving the efficiency of air transport,<BR>aimed at making a real difference over<BR>the next 10 years.<BR>Common validation of ATM<BR>concepts and CNS technologies<BR>Research has laid the foundation for the<BR>implementation of next generation ATM<BR>systems through standardisation and<BR>validation activities.Major advances have<BR>included the definition of a software<BR>platform to support large-scale validation<BR>and demonstration, the standardisation<BR>of interfaces between ATM domains, and<BR>the definition of a common approach<BR>to validation of concepts, functions and<BR>components.<BR>A<BR>A viable ATM concept for Europe has<BR>been defined for the timeframe 2005<BR>to 2010, building on Eurocontrol's<BR>ATM 2000+ strategy. It has two main<BR>elements:<BR> Layered planning and the introduction<BR>of a daily operational plan will<BR>help to optimise the management of<BR>available capacity.<BR> The introduction of additional<BR>computer-based tools will significantly<BR>reduce the workload for air traffic<BR>controllers per aircraft.<BR>An assessment covering technical,<BR>operational and socio-economic aspects<BR>has shown the feasibility of the concept,<BR>its benefits and related costs.<BR>The future ATM concept3<BR>© Eureka Slide,Von Bux<BR>© Eurocontrol<BR>SINGLE EUROPEAN SKY<BR>4 5<BR>An open and flexible validation platform has been<BR>developed for ATM. It was successfully tested using a set of<BR>existing Air Traffic Control (ATC) components provided by<BR>key European players.<BR>Further validation activities in current and future research<BR>programmes are expected to use this platform. It will enable<BR>validation activities to be readily set up and the results from<BR>different validation exercises to be directly compared.This will<BR>reduce the time required to gain acceptance for a new ATM<BR>component on a European level.The research demonstrated<BR>that the platform’s architecture works and is suitable for<BR>the anticipated validations.<BR>The specified ATM validation platform is a cornerstone of<BR>efforts to move on from the definition and design phase to<BR>subsequent implementation, and has obtained a wide consensus<BR>on architecture definition and platform development in the<BR>ATM industry. It was officially presented to the ATM industry<BR>and involved organisations in March 2001.<BR>An ‘open’ systems architecture4<BR>One research project has developed a prototype model that,<BR>for the first time, integrates land and air side analysis,<BR>incorporating microscopic models suitable for detailed analysis<BR>and macroscopic models suitable for strategic planning, while<BR>employing a common flight schedule to run different models.<BR>An evaluation study at the two Milan airports Linate and<BR>Malpensa revealed the strength and suitability of this<BR>approach, notably:<BR> the simplification of data preparation for analyses involving<BR>the entire airport, using a common flight schedule;<BR> the significant reduction of time and effort spent on airport<BR>analysis; and<BR> the provision of an effective tool for the identification of<BR>bottlenecks.<BR>Optimised airport modelling5<BR>An integrative approach towards<BR>airport management<BR>Airport modelling has previously<BR>concentrated on specific subsystems of<BR>the airport complex, such as the land side<BR>(terminals), the air side (runways and taxiways)<BR>and the access/egress system (roads, parking,<BR>etc.). However, users must manually<BR>co-ordinate inputs and outputs for<BR>the various models in order to account for<BR>the interaction between the airport<BR>subsystems. Similar co-ordination is required<BR>for users to mix strategic models (usually<BR>involving a low level of modelling detail)<BR>with tactical models (requiring a high level<BR>of detail in data and system definition). New<BR>research has overcome these limitations<BR>© Eureka Slide,Wang-Mo<BR>© EKA<BR>Adapting flight crews<BR>to new challenges<BR>In the last decade the aviation community<BR>has put considerable emphasis on nontechnical<BR>skills as one of the potential sources<BR>of progress on safety.The emergence of<BR>Crew Resource Management courses is<BR>among the most visible examples of this<BR>growing interest.<BR>Four major national aviation authorities, led<BR>by the European Joint Aviation Authorities<BR>(JAA), research centres, industry and<BR>the Commission have joined forces<BR>to elaborate suitable methods to evaluate<BR>non-technical or social skills, and<BR>subsequently achieve preliminary validation.<BR>In 1998 the "Non Technical Skills"<BR>(NOTECHS) method emerged, driven by<BR>the desire to minimise cultural and corporate<BR>differences, and to maximise practicality<BR>and effectiveness for airline instructors.<BR>Bridging the gap from the definition of<BR>the NOTECHS method to implementation<BR>and benchmarking has been the main<BR>task of a recent study on pilot training.<BR>Starting with a review of the existing<BR>methodology and its applicability, the<BR>experimental evaluation found<BR>NOTECHS to be a robust and sensitive<BR>assessment tool, and confirmed its<BR>usability alongside the mandatory<BR>regulations regarding the training of<BR>flight crews.The four main elements of<BR>the novel method are co-operative skills<BR>(e.g. team spirit and conflict solving),<BR>leadership and managerial skills<BR>(e.g. assertiveness and co-ordination),<BR>situational awareness (cognitive skills),<BR>and decision-making abilities<BR>(e.g. diagnosis, option analysis and risk<BR>assessment).<BR>Improving ‘non-technical skills’ 6<BR>© Eureka Slide, Balaes<BR>SINGLE EUROPEAN SKY<BR>6 7<BR>AREAS OF RESEARCH<BR>he main aims of air transport<BR>research have been to provide<BR>more efficient airspace control<BR>and management, to reduce<BR>environmental impacts, and to preserve<BR>and improve safety standards in line with<BR>international regulations.This has included<BR>efforts to establish a trans-European ATM<BR>network, and has been achieved through:<BR>• specification of ATM concepts and<BR>development of common architectures;<BR>• in-field trials of novel components at<BR>various European airports, research facilities<BR>and simulators; and<BR>• contributions to the international<BR>harmonisation of certification and<BR>operational procedures.<BR>The research has supported policy in five<BR>main areas:<BR>The ATM system for Europe<BR>Developing a single harmonised<BR>architecture for airspace control and<BR>management.<BR>Validation of advanced ATM<BR>technologies and concepts<BR>Developing a common validation<BR>environment for the assessment of<BR>candidate ATM technologies, components<BR>and sub-systems prior to live trials.<BR>Improved safety in aircraft<BR>operations<BR>Identifying gaps in current airworthiness<BR>requirements, promoting the safety<BR>of aircraft users and the targeted training<BR>of aircrew.<BR>Enhanced efficiency at airports<BR>Introducing advanced airside guidance<BR>and control systems for surface movements,<BR>and new approaches towards integrated<BR>airside and landside operations at airports.<BR>Changing working environments<BR>Investigating the impacts of novel<BR>technologies on air traffic control personnel<BR>and cockpit crews, and identifying<BR>appropriate transition training schemes.<BR>T<BR>THE ATM SYSTEM<BR>FOR EUROPE<BR>Next generation Communications,<BR>Navigation and Surveillance<BR>(CNS) technology7<BR>A new concept has been proposed,<BR>building on the use of geo-stationary<BR>satellites, to establish next generation<BR>Aeronautical Mobile en-Route Satellite<BR>Services. Such services would be valuable<BR>in high-density airspace areas,<BR>and the construction of a technical<BR>demonstrator is underway.The foreseen<BR>Europe-wide commercial market for<BR>such a system was estimated at some<BR>20 to 60 million Euro by the year 2008.<BR>The study recommended further activities<BR>to encourage next generation satellite<BR>and aircraft-based CNS applications in<BR>order to improve safety and capacity<BR>in ATM.<BR>Studies showed that the implementation<BR>of Airborne Separation Assurance<BR>System applications is feasible in the<BR>short term using the data available on<BR>board the majority of aircraft, once the<BR>remaining technical and institutional<BR>barriers have been overcome.<BR>These systems would allow for optimised<BR>use of air corridors without cockpit<BR>crews being widely dependent on<BR>ground-based Air Traffic Control (ATC)<BR>for in-flight guidance.<BR>he European Air Traffic<BR>Management (ATM) system can be<BR>considered as a "system of<BR>inter-dependent systems". Its purpose<BR>is to provide a safe, timely and orderly flow<BR>of air traffic, accommodating traffic<BR>demand, that is cost- effective, operates on<BR>the basis of uniform principles, satisfies<BR>national security requirements and is<BR>environmentally acceptable. In view of the<BR>rapid growth in demand for air travel, the<BR>European ATM system requires radical<BR>innovation and development.<BR>Technological contributions<BR>to future ATM systems<BR>New technological developments<BR>addressing the safety requirements of<BR>the European ATM system are emerging<BR>and need to be assessed.Therefore research<BR>has investigated advanced satellite systems,<BR>related broadcasting technology and<BR>on-board components to automate<BR>airborne separation.<BR>T<BR>© Eureka Slide,Domelounksen<BR>SINGLE EUROPEAN SKY<BR>8 9<BR>Noise abatement in the vicinity<BR>of airports 8<BR>Models for predicting noise exposure<BR>around airports have been evaluated,<BR>and recommendations made on<BR>the capabilities and key variables for<BR>modelling.<BR>Following this, noise abatement<BR>procedures were assessed using case<BR>studies based on the airports<BR>Amsterdam-Schiphol,Madrid-Barajas<BR>and Napoli-Capodichino. For the short<BR>term, promising operational procedures<BR>were found to be:<BR> an increased initial altitude before<BR>the aircraft enters its final glide slope;<BR> a reduced landing flap setting;<BR> delayed establishment of landing<BR>configuration (gear down, full flap<BR>extension);<BR> an optimised take-off procedure with<BR>rapid initial climb; and<BR> a continuous descent approach<BR>procedure (for use outside peak<BR>hours).<BR>Cost-benefit analysis highlighted<BR>the value of an approach procedure<BR>combining delayed stabilisation,<BR>reduced landing flap setting and<BR>an intercept altitude of 3000 ft for<BR>the start of the glide slope.<BR>This can reduce noise with no loss<BR>in airport capacity.<BR>Tackling the impacts<BR>of rapid air traffic growth<BR>Over the last 40 years, the steady increase<BR>in the number of flights and in urban<BR>developments around airports has greatly<BR>increased the exposure of the public to<BR>aircraft noise. Some improvements might<BR>be realised in the short term through changes<BR>in the way aircraft are operated (without<BR>any change in aircraft and air traffic control<BR>systems) ground systems and airborne<BR>equipment would help in the longer term<BR>over the next five to ten years (if developed<BR>to meet noise criteria).Therefore<BR>an inventory of current regulations and<BR>practices affecting aircraft noise has been<BR>compiled, together with a study of the<BR>operational, safety, capacity and economic<BR>constraints that might influence<BR>the definition of new procedures.<BR>VALIDATION OF ADVANCED ATM<BR>TECHNOLOGIES AND CONCEPTS<BR>The evaluation of several individual<BR>applications has provided the basis for<BR>verifying the overall capability of a single<BR>system solution for seamless gate-togate<BR>operations across CNS domains.<BR>Among the components assessed have<BR>been:<BR> Global Navigation Satellite System<BR>(GNSS) precision navigation capability<BR>en-route and during approach;<BR> on-ground situation awareness and<BR>taxi guidance;<BR> in-flight situational awareness;<BR> enhanced air traffic control<BR>surveillance;<BR> automatic terminal information service<BR>broadcast;<BR> extended helicopter surveillance; and<BR> runway incursion monitoring.<BR>Proposals for improvements in individual<BR>applications have been provided.<BR>The main recommendations at the<BR>system level include:<BR> accelerating the introduction of<BR>ADS-Broadcast (ADS-B) in Europe,<BR>which calls for close co-operation<BR>with airframe, ATC and airport system<BR>manufacturers;<BR> initiating cost/benefit analyses and<BR>developing operational procedures<BR>with respect to ADS-B;<BR> analysing certification issues and<BR>promoting the development of<BR>international standards for ADS-B;<BR> initiating research on human factors<BR>regarding cockpit layout of traffic<BR>information; and<BR> analysing safety, certification and<BR>operational approval aspects of using<BR>a common data link and a mix of<BR>CNS applications.<BR>New CNS applications 9<BR>The contribution<BR>of future communication systems<BR>he International Civil Aviation<BR>Organization has adopted<BR>an integrated ATM/CNS concept<BR>that envisages the use of data link<BR>communications, satellite navigation<BR>systems and Automatic Dependent<BR>Surveillance (ADS) in upcoming ATM<BR>systems.Today a range of dissimilar<BR>Communication, Navigation and<BR>Surveillance (CNS) systems support pilots<BR>and controllers in different phases of flight.<BR>The emergence of data link services creates<BR>an opportunity to establish integrated,<BR>seamless gate-to-gate services from<BR>departure to arrival of an aircraft.<BR>T<BR>© Courtesy of NEAP project<BR>SINGLE EUROPEAN SKY<BR>10 11<BR>Towards the stepwise introduction<BR>of new ATM technology<BR>The implementation of the necessary<BR>changes to the current ATM system in<BR>Europe will be gradual. Nevertheless, at<BR>each step, the new ATM system has<BR>to demonstrate advances in safety levels<BR>over the current system.<BR>This requires careful validation of<BR>the new concepts and systems prior<BR>to implementation.<BR>Building blocks<BR>of ATM validation10<BR>The ATM validation process covers<BR>regulatory issues (standards, legal<BR>frameworks), management and<BR>monitoring, and performance aspects<BR>related to preparation, design<BR>and reporting.<BR>From a survey of several validation<BR>activities, research has shown that many<BR>validation needs are not yet being met<BR>and that validation of a European ATM<BR>system as a whole is not manageable.<BR>A breakdown of the system into<BR>components will be needed for<BR>the purpose of validation.<BR>Therefore one research study proposed<BR>a system breakdown strategy for overall<BR>validation, consisting of 22 validation<BR>configurations corresponding to several<BR>different operational contexts.This<BR>breakdown has been assessed for two<BR>European target ATM systems – the<BR>current view of the system in 2005 and<BR>in 2015. In addition, short-term actions<BR>were identified relating to practical<BR>issues, such as the identification and<BR>implementation of validation platforms<BR>for the proposed configurations.<BR>A catalogue was compiled describing<BR>available facilities for validation. Also,<BR>inventories were made of validation<BR>tools existing or under development,<BR>and of gaps in system-level validation<BR>facilities.<BR>Member States of the European Civil<BR>Aviation Conference undertake<BR>validation of their ATM systems in<BR>a fairly rigorous, but generally<BR>inconsistent manner. Consequently,<BR>there is a need to harmonise the<BR>approaches and methodologies for<BR>validation in Europe. Research has<BR>recommended a validation process<BR>covering three main areas:<BR> a layered validation process<BR>identifying the most significant<BR>products of validation and providing<BR>a step-by-step approach to tackle<BR>validation in a harmonised manner;<BR> a toolbox of methods, techniques,<BR>tools and facilities for overall validation;<BR>and<BR> recommendations to harmonise the<BR>validation process at the European<BR>level in organisational terms.<BR>© Courtesy of NEAP project<BR>Safer aircraft<BR>mong in-flight hazards related to<BR>weather conditions, aircraft icing<BR>has always been one of the biggest<BR>issues in commercial aviation.<BR>Following major efforts in the 1940’s and<BR>50’s to investigate environmental<BR>conditions prone to formation of ice on<BR>aerodynamic surfaces, the resulting<BR>regulations have not been re-assessed in<BR>detail ever since. Due to a general increase<BR>in air traffic, and in particular the growing<BR>number of regional aircraft which are more<BR>sensitive to icing – due to lower operating<BR>altitudes and lower cruise speeds – there is<BR>renewed interest in solving this problem.<BR>IMPROVED SAFETY<BR>IN AIRCRAFT OPERATIONS<BR>A<BR>To understand the scope of the problem,<BR>a review was made of world-wide icingrelated<BR>accidents and incidents from<BR>1980 to 1995.These were fed into<BR>a database now accessible via<BR>the Internet.To complement this,<BR>a database was developed on existing<BR>icing atmosphere data.<BR>A flight test campaign with twin-engine<BR>turboprop aircraft investigated<BR>the Supercooled Large Droplet (SLD)<BR>conditions that trigger ice formation<BR>on airframe and wing.The existing<BR>regulations for design and certification<BR>of fixed-wing aircraft and helicopters<BR>were reviewed with respect to<BR>operation in icing conditions.<BR>In addition, feedback was sought from<BR>manufacturers of turboprop aircraft and<BR>rotorcraft on their experience with<BR>current icing standards, backed by<BR>interviews with operators about specific<BR>ice problems and crew training aspects.<BR>Several updates and extensions were<BR>proposed to the existing regulation to<BR>cover SLD conditions, and instruments<BR>were specified to measure these<BR>conditions and the characterisation of<BR>atmospheric phenomena.<BR>Tackling in-flight icing hazards11<BR>© Eureka Slide, Crunelle<BR>SINGLE EUROPEAN SKY<BR>12 13<BR>Test experience with currently used<BR>child restraint devices (CRD) in aircraft<BR>have been summarised in a research<BR>project and related to travel and<BR>accident statistics. Relevant aviation<BR>regulations have been discussed, and<BR>opinions on current practice have been<BR>sought from aviation authorities,<BR>operating airlines, cabin crews and<BR>consumer groups.<BR>The outcome has been aggregated in a<BR>Technical Reference Document covering<BR>bio-mechanical parameters that have to<BR>be considered when applying and using<BR>child restraint systems. Issues have been<BR>the definition of child groups, relevant<BR>test criteria applied to standard aircraft<BR>seats, specification of test dummies,<BR>categorisation of CRD tests, definition of<BR>test equipment, definition of standard<BR>adult seats, performance criteria to be<BR>adopted, and general concepts for the<BR>protection of children.<BR>This initiative led to a European<BR>specification for CRDs as a baseline<BR>for integrating the theme into<BR>certification and operational regulations<BR>by the Joint Aviation Authorities.<BR>The main parameters underlying these<BR>specifications are:<BR> the safe restraint of children to<BR>the standard of other passengers;<BR> the minimisation of additional costs<BR>to aviation industry;<BR> compatibility with European<BR>automobile restraint standards;<BR> harmonisation with the upcoming US<BR>standard;<BR> flexibility in CRD design;<BR> the inclusion of different flight phases<BR>(take-off and landing, cruise flight);<BR>and<BR> the need to use CRDs only for<BR>passengers of less than 18 kg weight.<BR>Improved safety for children in aircraft cabins 12<BR>Child safety<BR>Under current aviation regulations, the travel<BR>of infants and smaller children is not well<BR>covered in terms of safety, reflecting a lack of<BR>suitable restraint systems. Improvements in<BR>child safety are anticipated to be viable,once<BR>the required specifications for technical<BR>equipment and operational procedures have<BR>been defined and implemented.<BR>© Eureka Slide,M. Bingen<BR>ir traffic has grown at an average<BR>rate of 5% over the last 15 years,<BR>increasing the pressure on all<BR>aspects of Air Traffic Control (ATC).<BR>Capacity limitations at airports are a major<BR>bottleneck, with several main hubs and<BR>medium or small sized airports facing<BR>constraints on expansion and environmental<BR>concerns.While there is little chance<BR>to significantly enlarge existing airport<BR>infrastructures, the increasing number of<BR>aircraft movements (i.e. take-offs, landings<BR>and related taxiing) needs to be handled<BR>by using runways, taxiways and aprons<BR>more efficiently.<BR>Increasing tarmac capacity<BR>The planned Advanced Surface Movement<BR>Guidance and Control System (A-SMGCS) is<BR>intended to support the safe and efficient<BR>movement of aircraft and vehicles on<BR>an airport under all circumstances with<BR>respect to traffic density, visibility conditions<BR>and complexity of the airport layout.<BR>Simulations have shown that the expected<BR>improvement in traffic handling can be<BR>achieved, and specific functions have been<BR>demonstrated in real airport environments.<BR>ENHANCED EFFICIENCY<BR>AT AIRPORTS<BR>A<BR>The Advanced Surface<BR>Movement Guidance and Control<BR>System (A-SMGCS)13<BR>Two important research projects have<BR>dealt with the concept of integrated<BR>management of airport ground<BR>movements, demonstrating and testing<BR>prototype solutions.<BR>A demonstrator system for A-SMGCS<BR>has been implemented at four<BR>European airports, featuring the first<BR>large-scale demonstrator at<BR>Cologne/Bonn airport.The system<BR>architecture was designed to be<BR>modular and open.This can be used as<BR>a guideline by follow-on projects and<BR>for the realisation of a large-scale<BR>A-SMGCS implementation.<BR>Moreover, the advantages gained<BR>by data exchange during the trials<BR>motivated airports to enhance the<BR>integration of existing systems.<BR>Four areas were suggested for further<BR>investigation or improvement:<BR>surveillance, control, guidance<BR>and planning.<BR>A more complex approach has been to<BR>integrate an A-SMGCS prototype with a<BR>cockpit simulator and a tower simulator,<BR>both backed by several datalinks<BR>providing all relevant information<BR>for live simulation, in order to address<BR>the human/machine interface aspects<BR>of such a system.<BR>The simulations with the A-SMGCS<BR>platform were performed at Amsterdam-<BR>Schiphol and London-Heathrow airports,<BR>with remote connection to an aircraft<BR>simulator at Bedford (UK) and a tower<BR>simulator at Braunschweig (Germany).<BR>The evaluation of these trials generated<BR>a variety of ideas for better simulation<BR>tools from potential end users, such as<BR>air traffic controllers and pilots.<BR>The benefits and technical feasibility of<BR>an A-SMGCS multi-site, real-time,<BR>man-in-the-loop simulation platform<BR>has been underlined, in particular<BR>highlighting how to make best use of<BR>expensive simulation components that<BR>are typically scattered across several<BR>European research facilities.<BR>SINGLE EUROPEAN SKY<BR>14 15<BR>CHANGING<BR>WORKING ENVIRONMENTS<BR>he extraordinary growth of air<BR>transport has potential consequences<BR>for safety, requiring improvements<BR>in both the technical and operational<BR>aspects of Air Traffic Management (ATM).<BR>This means that the role of the human in<BR>conjunction with advanced automation has<BR>to be investigated. In addition, passenger<BR>survivability and human factors in flight<BR>operations have to be considered.<BR>Preparing the human operator to<BR>cope with future ATM concepts<BR>At present, all Air Traffic Management (ATM)<BR>responsibilities rest with the last human<BR>element in the responsibility chain, i.e.<BR>the controllers.This is a strong and well<BR>understandable reason for the reluctance of<BR>controllers to accept a new ATM system, in<BR>particular when they can no longer depend<BR>only on their own judgement or on the<BR>proof of what happened (e.g. via legal<BR>recording).This reduces their ability to<BR>control various traffic situations, whilst at<BR>the same time demands on them increase<BR>with traffic growth.This development<BR>presents a major challenge for the controllers.<BR>In-depth studies have looked at<BR>the differing perceptions of the amount<BR>of detail required for ATM certification<BR>across Europe, compared certification<BR>practices with those in other risk-critical<BR>domains, such as shipping, and analysed<BR>specific ATM certification problems.<BR>The human operator's performance in<BR>terms of ATM safety was assessed by<BR>means of stochastic models.<BR>A case study was performed on<BR>the safety impacts of advanced<BR>automation equipment in order to<BR>relate performance settings on<BR>automated sub-systems to overall safety<BR>design targets.<BR>The outcome has been a consolidated<BR>ATM certification framework that allows<BR>for effective safety management.<BR>The three main components are:<BR> an improved ATM safety certification<BR>framework for use by the various<BR>commercial actors;<BR> guidelines for change control in safetyrelevant<BR>ATM systems for controllers<BR>and pilots; and<BR> guidelines for the safety validation of<BR>automated ATM systems by<BR>manufacturers of those components.<BR>The human role in advanced ATM systems14<BR>T<BR>© Airbus<BR>The transition from conventional<BR>aircraft cockpits to state-of-the-art<BR>"glass cockpits", featuring few large<BR>displays and various digital controls,will<BR>have to take into account human factor<BR>standards, which have not been<BR>adequately addressed in training<BR>schemes so far.<BR>A comprehensive analysis of flight deck<BR>design philosophies employed by<BR>various aircraft manufacturers, focusing<BR>on automated flying functions such as<BR>steering,navigation, system management,<BR>communication and lookout has been<BR>complemented by an accident and<BR>incident review, identifying factors<BR>related to automated cockpits and poor<BR>transition training of crews.<BR>Investigations revealed that seven<BR>different skill groups could be identified<BR>relating to three principal types<BR>of individual behaviour, i.e. knowledgebased,<BR>rule-based and skill-based<BR>behaviour. An assessment of current<BR>training and transition activities at<BR>British Airways, Lufthansa and Airbus led<BR>to recommendations for a booklet on<BR>"Crew Resource Management for glass<BR>cockpits", containing a set of real-life<BR>incident scenarios. PC-based simulation<BR>software was evaluated for training<BR>purposes by performing tests with<BR>pilots from British Airways. As a result,<BR>specific recommendations have been<BR>formulated concerning training content,<BR>training methods and the associated<BR>training media.<BR>Transition training for cockpit crews 15<BR>Preparing flight crew for a new role<BR>The increase in automated tasks in<BR>the airline cockpit has changed the role of<BR>the crew from an active one to an apparently<BR>more passive one, supervising and managing<BR>automated systems.Many believe that this<BR>fundamental change in role has not<BR>received enough attention and that it may<BR>have led to crews not being adequately<BR>trained to perform their new supervisory<BR>and management tasks, resulting in a number<BR>of accidents and incidents attributable<BR>to human factors.<BR>The increase in<BR>automated tasks<BR>in the airline cockpit<BR>has changed the role<BR>of the crew from an<BR>active one to<BR>an apparently more<BR>passive one,<BR>supervising<BR>and managing<BR>automated systems.<BR>© Airbus<BR>16 17<BR>he transport research programme<BR>has shown that the problems facing<BR>air transport – more than for any<BR>other single transport mode – can<BR>only be met by harmonised and integrated<BR>approaches on a European level. Research<BR>has identified a set of candidate concepts,<BR>systems and measures – in particular in<BR>the ATM/CNS domain – and provided the<BR>information base and validation experience<BR>to support future implementation.<BR>While research to date has centred around<BR>the definition, architecture and design of Air<BR>Traffic Management (ATM) technologies,<BR>components and (sub-)systems, the focus of<BR>research in ongoing projects has shifted to<BR>large-scale validation of candidate ATM<BR>concepts.This will be followed by live trials<BR>of validated ATM concepts, ultimately leading<BR>to the large-scale implementation of<BR>reliable and modern systems across Europe.<BR>This move towards implementation is<BR>taking place in five main areas:<BR>• large scale validation of ATM (and CNS)<BR>concepts;<BR>• integration of airborne ATM systems and<BR>ground-based ATM systems;<BR>• optimisation of airport operations;<BR>• the sharing of experiences on airport<BR>activities;<BR>• human factors related training of air crews.<BR>The continuous growth in air transport<BR>demand can only be supported and<BR>sustained by full co-ordination between<BR>en-route ATM systems and airport planning<BR>operations. On-going research will assess<BR>the potential benefits of integrating<BR>Airport Traffic Management Systems<BR>that link existing ground, arrival and<BR>departure operations.<BR>CURRENT DEVELOPMENTS<BR>IN TRANSPORT RESEARCH<BR>This section identifies current<BR>research projects in the air transport<BR>sector. Further details are available<BR>from the Links section of the<BR>web-based Knowledge Centre.<BR>T<BR>SINGLE EUROPEAN SKY<BR>Thematic network<BR>on airport activities16<BR>An integrated approach to airport activities<BR>is needed to tackle the increasing ground<BR>congestion at European airports, which is<BR>most obvious with the lack of "slots", i.e. the<BR>time window assigned to an aircraft for<BR>take-off or landing.<BR>In order to provide solutions for the current<BR>situation, a substantial number of research<BR>activities have been launched, both at<BR>national and at European level.Therefore<BR>a framework for co-ordination has been<BR>created to increase transparency and<BR>effectiveness in the development of<BR>specific projects.<BR>A focal point for collaboration will be<BR>established where the main players can<BR>meet and exchange views.<BR>Important objectives are to avoid<BR>redundancy of work, to address the lack of<BR>consistency between European countries<BR>and to tackle the principal airport policy<BR>and regulation issues.<BR>© Eureka Slide<BR>A current research project aims to<BR>demonstrate the feasibility of integrating<BR>existing tools for arrival and departure<BR>planning management, together with<BR>those derived from the planning and<BR>routing function of ground movements.<BR>A full-scale integration of existing tools<BR>will be performed under real-life<BR>operating conditions at the airports<BR>Madrid-Barajas and Paris/Charles<BR>de Gaulle.<BR>The results of the operational assessment<BR>will provide a quantifiable measurement<BR>of the safety, capacity and efficiency<BR>benefits of such an integrated system.<BR>The most important outputs are expected<BR>to be a set of system design documents,<BR>test plans and evaluation reports.<BR>A complementary study is developing<BR>an integrated, networked simulation<BR>platform for modelling, evaluating and<BR>optimising airside and landside airport<BR>operations.This platform will have an<BR>open system architecture, which will<BR>enable future extensions.<BR>In a second step the simulation platform<BR>will be subject to validation and<BR>evaluation at six major European<BR>airports, namely Frankfurt, Amsterdam,<BR>Madrid, Barcelona (or Palma de Mallorca),<BR>Toulouse and Athens.However,<BR>the platform's architecture is adaptable<BR>for use in trials at other airports.<BR>Integrated airport operations17<BR>Evaluating the operational<BR>benefit of A-SMGCS18<BR>Full-scale systems for advanced surface<BR>movement, guidance and control<BR>(A-SMGCS) now need to be implemented.<BR>This will lead to the creation of industry<BR>rules for integration, including<BR>performance specifications,<BR>the generation of operational procedures<BR>adapted to the potential of the new<BR>technology, and user benefit validations.<BR>A current project is developing the<BR>A-SMGCS architecture for three airports,<BR>and establishing prototype installations<BR>at these airports with data exchange<BR>among the users. Proven A-SMGCS<BR>modules from industry and research<BR>organisations will be used, building on<BR>an operational concept in order to<BR>increase efficiency and safety.<BR>© Eureka Slide, Znam - Von Bux<BR>18 19<BR>References<BR>Further information on the following projects can be obtained from the web-based Knowledge Centre.<BR>Other key documents referenced in the brochure are available on the DG Energy and Transport web<BR>site (http://europa.eu.int/comm/dgs/energy_transport/index_en.html).<BR>1.White Paper "European transport policy for 2010: time to decide", COM(2001)370<BR>2.The transport research programme is part of the fourth framework programme for Community activities in the field<BR>of research, technological development and demonstration for the period 1994 to 1998<BR>3.TORCH project<BR>4. AVENUE project<BR>5.TAPE project<BR>6. JAR TEL project<BR>7.EMERTA project<BR>8. SOURDINE project<BR>9. NEAP project<BR>10. ASIVAL, CASCADE and GENOVA projects<BR>11. EURICE project<BR>12. IMPCHRESS project<BR>13. DEFAMM and SAMS projects<BR>14. ARIBA project<BR>15. ECOTTRIS project<BR>16.THENA project<BR>17. LEONARDO and OPAL projects<BR>18. BETA project<BR>Other useful publications:<BR>• European Aeronautics: A vision for 2020; Report of the group of personalities. Luxembourg: Office for Official<BR>Publications of the European Communities, 2001<BR>• Single European Sky; Report of the high-level group. Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European<BR>Communities, 2001<BR>The programme’s Knowledge Centre is available at:<BR>http://europa.eu.int/comm/transport/extra/home.html<BR>It provides:<BR>• structured guides to the results and projects for particular topics;<BR>• summaries and final reports of individual projects;<BR>• access to project web sites and other contact details.<BR>Brochures on results from the transport research programme<BR>are available for:<BR>1. Sustainable mobility<BR>2. Clean urban transport<BR>3. European transport networks<BR>4. Single European sky<BR>5. Maritime safety<BR>6. Freight intermodality<BR>7.Getting prices right<BR>8. Road safety<BR>9. Intelligent transport systems<BR>7 KO-39-01-538-EN-C<BR>OFFICE FOR OFFICIAL PUBLICATIONS<BR>OF THE EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES<BR>L-2985 LUXEMBOURG 感谢分享。
页:
[1]